Archive
Alternative Therapies

At the biennial International Headache Congress held last week in Dublin a group of Italian researchers presented a paper, Relationship between severity of migraine and vitamin D deficiency: a case-control study.

They examined 3 groups of subjects: 116 patients with chronic migraine, 44 patients with episodic migraine, and 100 non-headache controls. Ninety-two migraine patients had vitamin D insufficiency (borderline low levels), whereas 40 had a clear vitamin D deficiency. They found a strong inverse correlation between vitamin D levels and the severity of attacks as well as migraine-related disability.

This is only a correlational study, meaning that it does not prove that taking vitamin D will help relieve migraines. However, several neurological disorders seem to be associated with low vitamin D levels, suggesting that vitamin D is very important for the normal functioning of the nervous system. So it makes sense to keep your vitamin D levels at least in the middle of normal range.

Read More

An alarming study entitled Association Between Migraine Headaches and Dementia in More than 7,400 Patients Followed in General Practices in the United Kingdom was just published in the Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease. The researchers found that the risk for ALzheimer’s and other dementias is increased only in women with migraines and not in men.

The first large study to discover an association between migraines and dementia was done in Taiwan. Interestingly, a follow-up study in Taiwan discovered that people who used traditional Chinese medicine (mostly herbal products Jia-Wei-Xiao-Yao-San and Yan-Hu-Suo) had lower risk of dementia than those who did not.

There is no need to panic since other studies have found no such association and there is a wide range of preventive measures that are proven effective.

Controlling ones blood pressure, blood glucose, cholesterol level, and avoiding smoking are extremely important in lowering the risk of Alzheimer’s.

The single most effective preventive measure is regular physical exercise, which is more effective than mental exercise. Engaging in mental activities, such as learning languages, solving crossword puzzles, and playing bridge (which adds the benefit of social contacts) can also help. Dancing and tai chi combine physical and social benefits. Meditation appears to be effective in preventing shrinkage of the brain, which used to be thought a normal part of aging. This was confirmed in more than one study.

In addition to Chinese herbal products mentioned above, there are several other supplements that are also less proven but are safe and may help prevent Alzheimer’s. These include vitamins B12 and D, magnesium, curcurmin, nicotinamide, and possibly other.

Read More

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) has been definitively shown to alter brain connectivity and function. We are still enrolling patients in our double-blind study of tDCS for the prevention of migraines, so please contact us if you are interested.

A group of Iranian researchers used tDCS to treat “treatment-resistant major depression”. The results of this double-blind randomized sham-controlled trial were published in Clinical EEG and Neuroscience.

Patients with less than 50% decrease in the intensity of depression after 8 weeks of treatment with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (drugs like Prozac or fluoxetine, Lexapro or escitalopram, and other) were included in the trial. 16 women and 14 men were randomly allocated to an active group, which received 2-mA stimulation for 20 minutes per session, or the sham group. The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale was used to measure the severity of depression. There were statistically significant differences in the mean Hamilton scores in favor of the active treatment compared to the sham group. The difference in improvement persisted for a month after the treatment ended.

The authors’ conclusion that “tDCS is an efficient therapy for patients with resistant major depression, and the benefits would remain at least for 1 month” may be premature because of the small sample size. However, other studies have also indicated that tDCS may be effective in depression. Considering its low cost and very high safety, tDCS may be worth trying in patients with depression.

The same may apply to patients with migraines since several small studies have found this method effective. We hope that our larger study will confirm these findings. Our study differs from the previous ones and the ones for depression in that patients sue the device at home daily, rather than coming to the clinic to get the treatment. We hope that this difference will result in better outcomes.

Read More

Many migraine sufferers have gastro-intestinal problems, such as irritable bowel syndrome, constipation, sensitivity to gluten, dairy, and other types of foods. Nausea and vomiting and gastric stasis are common symptoms of migraine. All this indicates a close relationship between the gut and migraines. Considering that we contain more bacterial cells than our own (you may want to read a fascinating book by Ed Yong, I Contain Multitudes: The Microbes Within Us and a Grander View of Life), it is not surprising that certain types of bacteria may help prevent migraines.

Bio-Kult is a probiotic that contains 14 different strains of bacteria. It was tested for the prevention of migraine headaches in a double-blind placebo-controlled trial. I mentioned the preliminary results of this study presented in 2017 at the International Headache Congress, but the final results were only recently published in Cephalalgia. The researchers enrolled 100 patients and placed 50 of them into the placebo group and 50 into the probiotic group. 43 patients on the active therapy and 36 on placebo completed the trial. Patients with both chronic and episodic migraines (15 or more headache days a month makes it chronic) were included.

After 2 month of treatment, the mean frequency of migraine attacks and their severity were significantly reduced in the probiotic group compared to the placebo group. There was also a significant reduction of the number of abortive migraine medications taken by those in the probiotic group.

This was a small study with a high dropout rate, which means that it is far from proven that this type of probiotic is effective in treating migraine headaches. However, considering the safety of this product and its reasonable cost ($21 for a month supply on Amazon.com), it is worth a try after or in addition to more proven supplements such as magnesium and CoQ10.

Although the study was conducted in Iran, Bio-Kult is manufactured in the UK, which assures good quality. It has received “The Queen’s Awards for Enterprise”.

Read More

The role of vitamin B12 is underappreciated by many doctors. This week, The Wall Street Journal published a full-page article on vitamin B12 deficiency, which can be of great help to many of the two million readers of this newspaper. The survey quoted in the article shows that only one third of patients with this deficiency are diagnosed within a year, 22% within 1-2 years, 20% within 2-5 years 10% within 5-10 years and 14% after more than 10 years. It took several years for the author of the WSJ article to be diagnosed.

A confounding problem is that even if the doctor orders a vitamin B12 level, the widely used blood test is inaccurate. While the normal range is from 200 to 1,200 (depending on the laboratory), cases of severe deficiency have been described with levels of up to 700. You may have a good amount of vitamin B12 circulating in the blood, but it may not be getting into the cells where it is needed for the normal functioning of the nervous system, blood formation, and other functions. Many patients with a level above 200 are told by their doctors that their level is normal, but it should be at least over 400 and even better if it is above 500. We do have two additional blood tests that can confirm if the body needs additional vitamin B12 – homocysteine and methylmalonic acid levels but they are rarely utilized.

It is well worth your time to read the entire WSJ article.

I’ve written several times about the dangers of long-term treatment with PPIs, acid reducing drugs, such as Prilosec and Nexium. Among other side effects, they interfere with the absorption of vitamin B12 and other vitamins and minerals.

As far as headaches, vitamin B12 deficiency can be a contributing factor and taking vitamin B12 along with other B vitamins can relieve migraines.

Pain of facial neuralgia was found to be due to vitamin B12 deficiency in case studies of 17 patients and their pain resolved with vitamin B12 injections.

As the WSJ article suggests, many patients with neurological symptoms require regular injections rather than taking vitamin B12 pills. A couple of hundred of our patients come for monthly vitamin B12 injections, often along with an infusion of magnesium – another very common and highly underdiagnosed deficiency. It is not only migraines and other headaches that improve, but also fatigue, dizziness, and other symptoms.

Here is an old article from the Educational Materials section of our website.

Read More

Yet another study shows that low vitamin D level predisposes to neurological problems. A report just published in a leading neurology journal, Neurology by British and American researchers shows that low levels of vitamin D are associated with a higher risk of delirium in hospitalized patients.

This study looked at 313,121 participants, 544 of whom were hospitalized with delirium. The researchers proved that there is genetic evidence supporting connection between vitamin D levels and delirium. They called for trials of correction of low vitamin D levels for the prevention of delirium.

It is a strange call to action because we already know from other large studies that vitamin D deficiency predisposes to several neurological problems. These include not only migraines, but also multiple sclerosis, stroke, and other major diseases  Why not just make sure that nobody has a deficiency? Well, one reason is that insurance companies do not want to pay for the test because we do not have proof that correcting this deficiency will prevent these neurological problems. As we know, correlation does not mean causation. However, conducting large scale studies is very expensive and it takes many years to obtain the results. And why was a normal range for vitamin D was established if not to make sure that people are not deficient.

As I mentioned in my last post on vitamin D in 2015 everyone should have their vitamin D level checked and if you are deficient, get your level up to the middle of normal range. The normal range is 30 to 100, so below 40 is definitely not optimal.

Read More

Ginger is not only a popular spice, but a truly remarkable medicinal plant. Ginger’s proven anti-inflammatory properties may be responsible for its beneficial effects in migraine patients. Ginger may be effective for the treatment of seasickness, morning sickness of pregnancy and I recommend it for nausea of migraine as well.

A study published in the journal of the International Headache Society, Cephalalgia examined the effect of ginger, when added to an intravenous pain medication.

This was a double-blind placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial performed in the emergency room of a general hospital in Brazil. Adults who suffered from migraines with or without aura one to six times per month were included. Half of the sixty participants were given 400 mg of ginger extract (5% active ingredient) or placebo, in addition to an intravenous drug (100 mg of ketoprofen, a drug not available in the US in an injection, but it is similar to ketorolac, or Toradol) to treat an attack of migraine. Pain severity, functional status, migraine symptoms and treatment satisfaction were recorded.

Patients treated with ginger showed significantly better pain relief after 1, 1.5 and 2 hours. Ginger also significantly improved functional status and overall satisfaction.

Another double-blind study involving 100 patients compared the efficacy of ginger with sumatriptan in the treatment of an acute migraine attack. Patient satisfaction and their willingness to continue treatment was also evaluated after 1 month following intervention. Two hours after using either drug, mean headaches severity decreased significantly. Efficacy of ginger powder and sumatriptan was similar. Adverse effects of ginger powder were less than sumatriptan. Patient satisfaction was similar in two groups.

Considering that ginger has anti-inflammatory properties, it is possible taking it daily may also prevent migraines, although no preventive trials have been conducted to date.

Read More

To be eligible for this study you have to live in NYC or its suburbs and cannot be currently receiving Botox or a CGRP monoclonal antibody, such as Aimovig, Ajovy or Emgality.

PARTICIPATE IN MIGRAINE RESEARCH
A RANDOMIZED SHAM-CONTROLLED STUDY OF HOME-DELIVERED NON-INVASIVE NEUROSTIMULATION FOR MIGRAINE

• If you have frequent headaches (on 4 days or more/month) you may be eligible to enroll in a study of non-invasive neurostimulation aiming to reduce migraines.
• Neurostimulation provides stimulation of the nerves in the human body. Frequently used neurostimulation methods are for example, acupressure, acupuncture or TENS.
• This study uses a new neurostimulation method, tDCS. tDCS is a battery-powered device that delivers stimulation via two sponge pockets placed to a simple headband. Study participants will be assigned either to a group receiving active tDCS or to a control group receiving placebo tDCS.

If you are interested in more information about the study, please call the study personnel at 212-794-3550 or 212-440-1954 or email DrMauskop@nyheadache.com

Read More

Cefaly is a transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) device designed to treat migraine headaches by stimulating supraorbital nerves. The device was cleared by the FDA in 2014 for both acute and preventive treatment of migraine headaches. The preventive indication was based on a double-blind trial involving only 67 patients, while the use of Cefaly for acute migraines was based only on an open-label trial. A study recently published in Cephalalgia examined the efficacy of this device for acute treatment of migraines in a double-blind trial of 106 patients.

The trial confirmed that Cefaly is indeed effective for abortive therapy of migraine attacks. For prevention, it is recommended to use the device for 20 minutes every day, while to treat an acute attack the device should be used for an hour. The primary outcome measure was the mean change in pain intensity at 1 hour compared to baseline. This primary outcome measure was significantly more reduced in the stimulation group compared to the sham group: 60% versus 30% reduction. No serious adverse events were reported and five minor adverse events occurred in the stimulation group. I’ve had one or two patients report that the device actually triggered a migraine, but this can also happen with any oral migraine drug.

The main reason I offer Cefaly before any other device (eNeura TMS or gammaCore) is that it is the most affordable. The price has gone up since it’s introduction and ranges from $350 to $500, however the manufacturer offers a 60-day return policy. This is long enough to see if it is effective. Cefaly is sold only with a doctor’s prescription, which is uploaded to the Cefaly website (Cefaly.us for US patients and Cefaly.com for the rest of the world).

Read More

Several older reports have suggested an association between dry eye disease (DED) and migraine headaches. Researchers at the Univercity of North Carolina at Chapel Hill just published a large and convincing study confirming this comorbidity.

This was a retrospective study which included 72,969 patients older than 18 years seen over a period of 10 years. The study included 41,764 men and 31,205 women. Of these, 5,352 patients (7.3%) were diagnosed to have migraine headaches and 9,638 (13.2%) had the diagnosis of DED. The odds of having DED and migraine headaches was 1.4 times higher than that of patients without migraine headaches. This association was true for men and women older than 65 and women of all ages. Older age and female sex are both risk factors for the development of DED, probably due to hormonal and age-related changes.

The incidence of migraines and DED in the general population are reversed – about 12% suffer from migraines and 7% from DED, which is probably due to the fact that the study included only patients see at ophthalmology clinics.

The authors conclude that patients with migraine headaches are more likely to have comorbid DED compared with the general population, but this association may not reflect cause and effect. Both conditions do share inflammation as one of the underlying processes.

It is very likely that the eye discomfort from DED can be making migraines more frequent and severe. The diagnosis of DED should be considered in all migraine sufferers, especially in those with difficult to control attacks because effective treatment of DED could lead to an improvement in migraines.

Read More

A study just published in Neurology by the MEGASTROKE project of the International Stroke Genetics Consortium found that “genetically higher serum magnesium concentrations are associated with a reduced risk of cardioembolic stroke…” It is an open access article, so you can download the full text. The study looked at 34,217 cases of strokes and 404,630 noncases, which makes the data highly reliable.

Here are some quotes (some modified) from the paper.

Several observational prospective studies have reported that low circulating magnesium concentrations and low magnesium intake are associated with increased risk of stroke. In the Nurses’ Health Study, low plasma magnesium concentrations were associated with an approximately 70% to 80% increased risk of embolic and thrombotic stroke.

Magnesium may in part reduce the risk of cardioembolic stroke through its antiarrhythmic effects and via atrial fibrillation. Low serum magnesium concentrations are associated with increased risk of atrial fibrillation, which is a strong risk factor for cardioembolic stroke. (My recent post mentioned that the increased risk of strokes in patients with migraines with aura is possibly related to the higher incidence of atrial fibrillation) Two of the magnesium-associated SNPs (genetic variants) were significantly associated with atrial fibrillation, with higher serum magnesium concentrations being associated with lower risk of atrial fibrillation.

Magnesium also has anticoagulant and antiplatelet properties (platelet aggregation is also implicated in migraine). Magnesium is considered to be nature’s calcium blocker as it suppresses many of the physiologic actions of calcium. For example, calcium promotes blood coagulation, whereas magnesium suppresses blood clotting and thrombus formation and reduces platelet aggregation. Antithrombotic effects may lead to reduction in risk of both cardioembolic and large artery stroke.

Other possible mechanisms whereby high serum magnesium concentrations may reduce ischemic stroke risk include improvement of endothelial function and reduction in blood pressure, atherosclerotic calcification, arterial stiffness, oxidative stress, fasting glucose concentration, insulin resistance, and risk of type 2 diabetes. Some of those beneficial e?ects may also lead to a reduction in small vessel stroke, which was not observed in this study.

Magnesium also reduces the size of a hemorrhagic stroke (bleeding into the brain), according a another recent study.

Magnesium has been my main area of research and because I never tire of promoting the role of magnesium in the treatment of migraines some colleagues call me Dr. Magnesium. The evidence is overwhelming – many studies have shown that magnesium deficiency is common in migraine sufferers and that taking magnesium can help. The American Academy of Neurology and the American Headache Society guidelines for the treatment of migraines include magnesium, but it is still underappreciated and underutilized. This is in part because there have been no large-scale (i.e. expensive) trials of magnesium which are done by pharmaceutical companies for new drugs. Another reason is that the trials that have been conducted supplemented migraine patient regardless of their magnesium status – both deficient and non-deficient patients were given magnesium, thus obscuring the great benefit obtained by the deficient cohort.

As mentioned in several previous posts, magnesium also helps asthma, palpitations, feeling cold or having cold hands and feet, muscle twitching, cramps or diffuse muscle aches (fibromyalgia), premenstrual symptoms (PMS), brain fog, and many other symptoms. If you have any of these symptoms you may want to have a blood test for magnesium. And even if you don’t have symptoms, the next time you have any kind of a routine blood test, ask your doctor to add a test for “RBC magnesium”, which is more accurate than the usual “serum magnesium”.

If you have any of the above symptoms, you can also just start taking 400 mg of magnesium glycinate, which is the daily recommended allowance for magnesium. If oral magnesium does not help and the RBC magnesium level is low we usually give monthly infusions of magnesium. They take 10 minutes to do, have no side effects and are covered by most insurance plans.

Read More

Having conducted and published research on magnesium and seeing dramatic improvement from magnesium in many of my patients, I try to write about magnesium at least once a year. Up to half of migraine sufferers are deficient in magnesium and could greatly benefit from it.

Magnesium supplements are considered “probably effective” for the prevention of migraine headaches, according to the American Headache Society and American Academy of Neurology guidelines. The reason magnesium is listed as only probably effective is poor design of most clinical trials. There was no selection of patients – magnesium was given to all without any regard to their magnesium status. Obviously, those who did not have a deficiency did not benefit from taking magnesium and they diluted positive results seen in those who were deficient.

A study conducted by researchers at George Mason University looked at the dietary and supplement data of 2,820 American adults between 20 and 50 years old. They found that higher dietary intake of magnesium led to lower risk of migraines in both men and women. This relationship was even stronger in women, but not men who took magnesium supplements.

They also found that the average consumption of magnesium in these 2,820 Americans was only 70%-75% of the Recommended Dietary Allowance. Obviously, it is better to get your magnesium from food, such as whole grains, dark leafy vegetables, avocados, legumes, and other. However, changing your diet is not easy, so the second best choice is to take a supplement. I recommend 400 mg of magnesium glycinate, but other magnesium salts can also help.

About 10%-20% of our patients who are deficient in magnesium either do not absorb magnesium (we check their RBC magnesium levels) or do not tolerate it and get diarrhea. They do very well with a monthly intravenous infusion of magnesium.

Magnesium has many benefits besides relieving migraines, including possibly preventing Alzheimer’s disease, reducing the size of a stroke, post-concussion syndrome, fibromyalgia, palpitations, asthma, muscle cramps, “brain fog”, and other symptoms.

Read More