Tonight at 6 PM (EST), Dr. Mauskop will speak at the Weekly Wellness with the American Migraine Foundation. He will discuss the role of exercise in the management of migraine headaches and the results of scientific clinical trials, as well as practical information about various types of exercise such as aerobic (cardiovascular), isometric, high-intensity interval testing, and the Feldenkrais method. He will also provide advice on how to avoid exercise-induced and exertional headaches. You can log in to see this event and ask questions here – https://www.facebook.com/events/730534437480323/
Read MoreIt is hard to think or write about anything other than Covid-19, so here is some information on Covid-19 and headaches.
The bad news is that the long-suffering headache patients are suffering more. Most hospitals consider Botox injections, nerve blocks, and other procedures to treat headaches as “nonessential”. Yes, our patients will not die like some of those with Covid-19, but a more nuanced approach than just canceling all “nonessential” procedures should’ve been possible. My NYC colleagues are not needed to treat Covid-19 patients and they are just sitting around worrying about their patients and their own futures. We are a private headache clinic and are continuing to see patients in our office (with all the precautions) for Botox and other procedures, although the number of patients we are treating has dropped by three quarters. Most are understandably concerned about contracting the virus and are staying home.
As far as the relationship between Covid-19 and headaches, it appears that this virus can sometimes invade the brain. This is not surprising because many viruses that affect the respiratory system can also affect the brain. The brain symptoms of Covid-19 are similar to those seen with other brain infections, including headaches (at times with nausea and vomiting), seizures, and disturbed consciousness. Loss of sense of smell is very characteristic of Covid-19 and it happens because of the damage to olfactory nerves. These nerve endings line the nasal cavity and they are directly connected to cell bodies of neurons in the brain. This is one of the possible routes of entry of the virus into the brain.
Recent reports suggest that Covid-19 causes blood clotting in small blood vessels of the lungs, which may be contributing to deaths in some patients. A few cases of strokes in Covid-19 patients have been reported, although it is not clear if blood clotting or even the virus itself were responsible. The Mt. Sinai Hospital system to which I belong just issued guidance for the use of blood thinners in Covid-19 patients. This could be life-saving for some critically ill people.
All this may sounds very alarming, but fortunately, most neurological and other symptoms of Covid-19 resolve in over 99% of patients. The mortality rate of Covid-19 seems higher than 2% only because there are so many people who had the infection with mild or no symptoms and those people are not included in the calculations of mortality rates.
One silver lining is that now we all practice telemedicine. The technology has existed for years, but a major obstacle has been the unwillingness of insurance companies to pay for telemedicine visits. The telehealth parity law was actually passed in NYS in 2016. This pandemic will make televisits much more commonplace. Telehealth law excludes audio-only and electronic messaging-only. Fortunately, there are several HIPAA-compliant video platforms that make televisits easy to conduct. Less than half of our patients need to be in the office for a procedure while the rest can be safely and effectively treated remotely. Most people have busy lives and not having to trudge to the office will save them hours of time.
Read MoreOnabotulinumtoxinA (Botox) is a most remarkable medicine. It was first approved by the FDA in 1989 for two eye conditions and since then it received approval for another dozen conditions as varied as excessive sweating, very frequent urination, spasm of muscles, and of course, migraines.
An interesting chain of serendipitous discoveries led to its approval for migraines. A Vancouver ophthalmologist, Dr. Jean Carruthers started using Botox in 1987 to treat blepharospasm (forceful and uncontrollable blinking) and noticed that patients’ wrinkles disappeared. She mentioned this to her husband-dermatologist Dr. Alastair Carruthers who began to inject it for cosmetic reasons. Then a plastic surgeon in California, Dr. William Binder who has been using Botox to treat wrinkles began hearing from his patient that their headaches went away along with their wrinkles.
When Dr. Binder first presented his observation in the early 1990s, he was met with a lot of skepticism. How could Botox, which affects only superficial muscles and nerve endings, help migraine, which begins deep in the brain? And what does a plastic surgeon really know about headaches? I was also a bit skeptical but faced with many patients whose migraines would not respond to usual treatments, I decided to look into this.
I discovered that by weight, Botox is the deadliest poison known to man. At the same time, it is safer than aspirin, ibuprofen, or acetaminophen because obviously any drug can become a poison depending on the amount you ingest. Thousands of people die every year from bleeding ulcers or kidney problems caused by aspirin and ibuprofen and thousands die from liver damage caused by acetaminophen, but deaths from Botox are extremely rare. Last year I visited Allergan’s manufacturing plant in Ireland where all of the world’s supply of cosmetic and medical Botox is manufactured. On our tour of the plant, we were told that one year’s supply of Botox weighs 1 gram. Each 100-unit vial of Botox contains 5 nanograms (0.000000005 gram) of the toxin.
I was the first neurologist in New York to use Botox for migraines and even though I am a headache specialist and not a plastic surgeon, many of my colleagues were disdainful. Others came to learn the technique I developed. Even before the FDA approval, over 200 doctors from around the world visited our center. It took us a few years to convince Allergan to do clinical trials and then quite a few years to conduct these trials, but in 2010 the FDA approved Botox for the treatment of chronic migraines.
I’ve written several blog posts on the various aspects of Botox therapy including its use off-label (without having an FDA approval) for children with migraines, TMJ disorders, trigeminal neuralgia, post-concussion headaches, common avoidable problems seen with the injections, and about underutilization of this remarkable drug for the treatment of migraines.
Incredibly, the chain of serendipitous discoveries continues – patients treated for migraines reported to feel depressed and this was not because their headaches improved since depression also lifted in patients whose migraines did not improve. And so, this 30-year-old drug continues to find new uses.
Read MoreRimegepant (NURTEC ODT) is the second gepant approved for the acute treatment of migraine headaches. It blocks the same CGRP pathway as the injectable monoclonal antibodies that are used for the prevention of migraine attacks (erenumab/Aimovig, fremanezumab/Ajovy, galcanezumab/Emgality, and eptinezumab/Vyepti). It follows the recent introduction of a similar drug that also blocks the CGRP receptor, ubrogepant (Ubrelvy).
Since there have been no head-to-head trials comparing these two gepants, it is had to say if one is better than the other. On average, they appear to be very similar, but this does not mean that they will be equally effective or cause the same side effects in a particular patient. We see this with triptans (drugs like sumatriptan, eletriptan, and other) – the top 5 show similar efficacy in trials, but some patients strongly prefer one over another.
One difference is that rimegepant is an orally disintegrating tablet and does not require water, while ubrogepant is taken with water. This makes rimegepant easier to take on the go and could be easier to take for patients with severe nausea. Another minor difference is that the dose of rimegepant is 75 mg that is taken once a day, while ubrogepant comes in 50 and 100 mg tablets and either dose can be repeated for up to 2 tablets a day. This can be both an advantage and a disadvantage. The instructions are simple for rimegepant – take one tablet once on the day you have a migraine (and the earlier you take any abortive drug the better). With ubrogepant the doctor has to decide whether to give 50 or 100 mg dose and the patient needs to be instructed to take a second dose on the same day (as soon as 2 hours after the first one) if the headache returns or does not completely resolve with the first dose. In clinical trials, this second dose did produce additional improvement.
The safety of rimegepant is as remarkable as that of ubrogepant and the preventive injectable monoclonal antibodies. Rimegepant caused nausea in 2% of patients compared with 0.4% of those on placebo and less than 1% developed a rash or temporary difficulty breathing.
Read MoreNortriptyline (Pamelor) is a tricyclic antidepressant approved by the FDA only for the treatment of depression. However, with the introduction of SSRI family of antidepressants such as fluoxetine (Prozac) which have fewer side effects, the use of tricyclic antidepressants for depression has declined.
Tricyclic antidepressants are still in wide use, but mostly for the treatment of headaches and pain. Nortriptyline is very similar to amitriptyline (Elavil) and is thought to cause fewer and milder side effects, although this has not been proven. This could be due to the fact that amitriptyline is broken down into nortriptyline, which is the active metabolite. Amitriptyline tends to be more sedating, which can be useful in patients with insomnia.
There are no good blinded studies of nortriptyline for the prevention of migraines and they are not likely to be done. We assume it is as good as amitriptyline, although studies of amitriptyline also lack in size and scientific rigor.
There are many trials of amitriptyline and nortriptyline for various pain conditions, but they are also not up to our modern standards. Amitriptyline was approved in the US in 1961.
Besides sedation, nortriptyline can cause dry mouth, constipation, urinary retention in older patients, and other side effects. The dose to treat migraines and pain is usually lower than the dose used to treat depression. Pain and headaches sometimes respond to as little as 10 or 25 mg while for depression, the dose goes up to 100 mg and higher.
In short-term studies of major depression, antidepressants increased the risk of suicidal thinking and behavior in children, adolescents, and young adults. This is less likely to occur when treating pain, but many pain patients also experience depression.
Read MoreEptienzumab (Vyepti) was just approved by the FDA for the preventive treatment of migraine headaches. Eptinezumab is another monoclonal antibody that blocks the effect of CGRP, a chemical released during a migraine attack. It joins erenumab (Aimovig), fremanezumab (Ajovy), and galcanezumab (Emgality), three other monoclonal antibodies approved for the preventive treatment of migraine headaches.
Eptinezumab is different from the other three drugs in that it is administered intravenously. It is given every three months by an infusion over 30 minutes. The other three drugs are self-administered subcutaneously every month, although fremaezumab can be also given every 3 months.
Eptinezumab may also have a faster onset of action because it is administered intravenously and quickly reaches its peak concentration in the blood. The other three drugs take up to a week to reach their maximum concentration. The reason for such a long delay (most drugs injected subcutaneously take less than an hour to peak) is that the monoclonal antibodies are large molecules and are distributed not by blood vessels, but the slow-moving lymphatic system. On the other hand, these are preventive therapies, so the speed of onset is less critical than for abortive drugs, such as NSAIDs, triptans, and gepants (ubrogepant, rimegepant).
Theoretically, it is possible that eptinezumab could work for patients who do not respond to the other three drugs because of a better distribution of the drug and because these drugs are not identical. About 10% of my patients report significantly better response when switched from erenumab, which was first to be approved, to either fremanezumab or galcanezumab.
We don’t know yet what the drug will cost and how well the insurance companies will pay for it. All three subcutaneous drugs cost about $650 a shot and all three manufacturers offer a one-year free trial if the insurance refuses to pay. This does not apply to patients who have Medicare or Medicaid, which do not allow free trials or discount coupons. Fortunately, more and more insurers, including the government plans, are covering these drugs, albeit with some paperwork that needs to be completed by the doctor. The cost of eptinezumab will consist of two parts – the cost of the drug and the cost of the infusion.
Read MoreMilnacipran (Savella) is a drug that is approved by the FDA for the treatment of fibromyalgia. Fibromyalgia is a chronic disorder characterized by widespread musculoskeletal pain, fatigue, and tenderness in localized areas.
Milnacipran belongs to the category of selective serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs), which are used to treat anxiety, depression, and pain. There are four other SNRIs that are approved for the treatment of anxiety and depression, and in case of duloxetine (Cymbalta) also for fibromyalgia, peripheral nerve damage due to diabetes and musculoskeletal pain.
The manufacturer of milnacipran decided not to seek approval for the treatment of depression to avoid the stigma of being an antidepressant drug. Many patients feel that if they are prescribed an antidepressant, their pain is not perceived as real physical pain, but rather purely psychological.
Milnacipran was tested for the preventive treatment of migraines only in one unblinded observational study. Not surprisingly, it was effective. We often use duloxetine and venlafaxine (Effexor) for the treatment of migraines. Fibromyalgia, back pain, and other pains are comorbid with migraines, meaning that if you have one condition, you are more likely to have the other as well. Such patients are ideal candidates for SNRIs, although tricyclic antidepressants such as amitriptyline also work well for any pain and migraines.
Just like with other SNRIs, the most common side effects include nausea, headache, constipation, dizziness, insomnia, hot flushes, hyperhidrosis (excessive sweating), vomiting, palpitations, increased heart rate, dry mouth, and hypertension. Another common problem with these drugs is that many patients develop very unpleasant withdrawal symptoms if the drug is stopped abruptly.
Theoretically, antidepressants when used with triptans, such as sumatriptan can cause serotonin syndrome, but it is extremely rare and millions of people take both without any problems.
Read MoreWhen sumatriptan (Imitrex) was introduced in 1992 it was truly a breakthrough drug – the first drug specifically developed for the acute treatment of migraines. Sumatriptan and six other triptans have alleviated suffering of millions of people. Sumatriptan is considered to be the gold standard therapy for an acute migraine. Unfortunately, 27 years later many millions of migraine sufferers have not had a chance to try these drugs.
A study by R. Lipton and his colleagues presented earlier this year surveyed 15,133 migraine sufferers. Only 37% had ever used a triptan and only 16% were using them at the time of the survey. Most patients used tablets, but 11% also tried either a nasal spray or an injection. Lack of efficacy (in 38%) and side effects (in 22%) were the most common reason for stopping the drug and the most common side effects were dizziness, nausea, and fatigue.
My guess is that lack of efficacy is often due to the suboptimal dose of a triptan that is often prescribed. I see many patients who tell me that they’ve tried sumatriptan and it did not work, but many of them took 25 or 50 mg, while an effective dose for most patients is 100 mg. Most other triptans are also available in two different strengths and the lower, less effective dose is often prescribed.
Another common problem is that patients who fail one triptan due to side effects or lack of efficacy are not prescribed a different triptan. Many of my patients find that one triptan is more effective than another or if one triptan causes side effects, a different one may not. Also, if a tablet does not work, an injection or a nasal spray might, especially in patients with a quick buildup of pain or when nausea is present.
A big reason for the underutilization of triptans is misdiagnosis of headaches. Almost half of migraine sufferers are told that they have sinus or tension headaches, which means they are missing out on receiving effective treatment.
Safety of triptans is a concern of many physicians and patients. The package insert warns about strokes and heart attacks and it is true that if you have untreated hypertension, coronary artery disease or many risk factors for coronary artery disease it is better to avoid triptans. However, triptans have been available without a prescription for over 10 years in most European countries.
A panel of leading headache specialists published a “Consensus Statement: Cardiovascular Safety Profile of Triptans in the Acute Treatment of Migraine” that states “The incidence of serious cardiovascular events with triptans in both clinical trials and clinical practice appears to be extremely low “.
Another unfounded concern of many physicians is that frequent use of triptans will make migraines more frequent and severe. There is no good scientific evidence for this concern. You can read my two previous blog posts on this topic here and here. The first of these two posts is by far the most popular on this site with over 300 comments. Many patients report how relieved they are to hear that they are not risking their lives by taking triptans often or even daily and also how frustrated they are not being able to find a doctor who would prescribe a sufficient amount of this medicine.
Sumatriptan was first released in a pack of 9 tablets, but not because it was dangerous to take more, but mostly because this was the average number of tablets people used in one month in clinical trials. Cost used to be another limiting factor and some insurers still limit triptans to 6 or 9 tablets a month. However, generic sumatriptan now can be found for as little as $12-20, so patients can bypass their insurance and buy as many additional tablets as they might need.
Read MoreMemantine (Namenda) is an Alzheimer’s drug that has been used for the treatment of pain and migraine headaches. This drug blocks the NMDA receptor in the brain, which is involved in the processing of pain messages and in other neurological conditions such as epilepsy, stroke and traumatic brain injuries.
NMDA receptor antagonist dizocilpine, or MK801 was a drug with a potential to treat all these conditions, but unfortunately it had serious side effects and after spending hundreds of millions of dollars, Merck stopped its development. It is possible that strong inhibition of the NMDA receptor will always lead to serious side effects. We do have several other milder NMDA inhibitors, besides memantine – dextromethorphan, which is used as a cough suppressant and ketamine.
Memantine, 10 to 20 mg a day was studied in 28 patients with migraines that were not responding to at least two standard medications and was found to be effective. A double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 10 mg of memantine in 52 patients was also positive. Another double-blind placebo-controlled trial of 60 patients also showed some benefit. A review of case reports and two controlled studies concluded that memantine, 10 to 20 mg a day may be an effective treatment for the prevention of migraines. A study of 40 mg of memantine for chronic tension-type headaches did not show any efficacy, although women seemed to benefit more than men. The only side effects of this relatively high dose (the Alzheimer’s dose is 20 mg) were nausea and dizziness. Overall, memantine tends to be well tolerated, even in the elderly with Alzheimer’s.
I do occasionally prescribe memantine and tend to increase the dose to 20 mg twice a day. I have only a few patients who obtained very good relief and remain on the drug. It is certainly not the first, second, or third drug I prescribe, but when many other drugs fail, it is worth a try since potential side effects are relatively mild.
Read MoreA large study confirms previous reports of the beneficial effect of onabotulinumtoxinA (Botox) injections on depression as well as anxiety. In my two previous blog posts from 2011 and 2014 I mentioned reports of cosmetic Botox injections relieving depression but those involved a relatively small number of patients.
A study published in the Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, & Psychiatry under the title Effects of onabotulinumtoxinA treatment for chronic migraine on common comorbidities including depression and anxiety ,described the COMPEL trial (Chronic Migraine OnabotulinumtoxinA Prolonged Efficacy Open-Label). It was a multicenter, open-label, prospective study assessing the long-term safety and efficacy of 155 units of onabotulinumtoxinA (Botox) over nine treatments (108 weeks) in adults with chronic migraines.
OnabotulinumtoxinA treatment was associated with sustained reduction in headache days and depression and anxiety scores in the 715 patients over 108 weeks. The anxiety and depression scores were significantly reduced at all time points in patients with clinically significant symptoms of depression and/or anxiety at baseline. By week 108, 78% and 82% had clinically meaningful improvement in depression and anxiety symptoms, respectively. Sleep quality and symptoms of fatigue also improved.
In an earlier poster presentation of this data at a scientific conference the authors reported that the improvement in anxiety and depression was seen even in patients whose migraines did not improve with Botox. Even if that were true, we need a separate large study of Botox for anxiety and depression. The one study that treated patients with major depression in a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial involved only 74 patients.
In my practice, I’ve treated one young woman with severe bipolar disorder which did not respond to multiple drugs and who had a dramatic response to Botox. She has been receiving injections for over two years with sustained improvement. Another young man with depression had a very significant response as well, but has had only one treatment so far. I came to treat them accidentally – both were adopted children of my migraine patient who read about this possible effect of Botox and asked me to try it.
Read MoreTranscranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) has been definitively shown to alter brain connectivity and function. We are still enrolling patients in our double-blind study of tDCS for the prevention of migraines, so please contact us if you are interested.
A group of Iranian researchers used tDCS to treat “treatment-resistant major depression”. The results of this double-blind randomized sham-controlled trial were published in Clinical EEG and Neuroscience.
Patients with less than 50% decrease in the intensity of depression after 8 weeks of treatment with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (drugs like Prozac or fluoxetine, Lexapro or escitalopram, and other) were included in the trial. 16 women and 14 men were randomly allocated to an active group, which received 2-mA stimulation for 20 minutes per session, or the sham group. The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale was used to measure the severity of depression. There were statistically significant differences in the mean Hamilton scores in favor of the active treatment compared to the sham group. The difference in improvement persisted for a month after the treatment ended.
The authors’ conclusion that “tDCS is an efficient therapy for patients with resistant major depression, and the benefits would remain at least for 1 month” may be premature because of the small sample size. However, other studies have also indicated that tDCS may be effective in depression. Considering its low cost and very high safety, tDCS may be worth trying in patients with depression.
The same may apply to patients with migraines since several small studies have found this method effective. We hope that our larger study will confirm these findings. Our study differs from the previous ones and the ones for depression in that patients sue the device at home daily, rather than coming to the clinic to get the treatment. We hope that this difference will result in better outcomes.
Read MoreMany migraine sufferers have gastro-intestinal problems, such as irritable bowel syndrome, constipation, sensitivity to gluten, dairy, and other types of foods. Nausea and vomiting and gastric stasis are common symptoms of migraine. All this indicates a close relationship between the gut and migraines. Considering that we contain more bacterial cells than our own (you may want to read a fascinating book by Ed Yong, I Contain Multitudes: The Microbes Within Us and a Grander View of Life), it is not surprising that certain types of bacteria may help prevent migraines.
Bio-Kult is a probiotic that contains 14 different strains of bacteria. It was tested for the prevention of migraine headaches in a double-blind placebo-controlled trial. I mentioned the preliminary results of this study presented in 2017 at the International Headache Congress, but the final results were only recently published in Cephalalgia. The researchers enrolled 100 patients and placed 50 of them into the placebo group and 50 into the probiotic group. 43 patients on the active therapy and 36 on placebo completed the trial. Patients with both chronic and episodic migraines (15 or more headache days a month makes it chronic) were included.
After 2 month of treatment, the mean frequency of migraine attacks and their severity were significantly reduced in the probiotic group compared to the placebo group. There was also a significant reduction of the number of abortive migraine medications taken by those in the probiotic group.
This was a small study with a high dropout rate, which means that it is far from proven that this type of probiotic is effective in treating migraine headaches. However, considering the safety of this product and its reasonable cost ($21 for a month supply on Amazon.com), it is worth a try after or in addition to more proven supplements such as magnesium and CoQ10.
Although the study was conducted in Iran, Bio-Kult is manufactured in the UK, which assures good quality. It has received “The Queen’s Awards for Enterprise”.
Read More
Recent Comments