Archive
New treatments

Cluster headache patients have been coming to our office in increasing numbers in the past few weeks. We seem to be in a cluster season – many patients with cluster headaches come within the same month or two and then, for several months we see very few cluster patients. Many cluster headache sufferers ask about the efficacy of LSD, hallucinogenic mushrooms and seeds.

The use of hallucinogens for cluster headaches was first reported by a Scottish man in 1998. He started using LSD for recreation and for the first time in many years had a year without cluster headaches. The first report in scientific literature appeared in 2006 in the journal Neurology. Dr. Sewell and his colleagues surveyed 53 cluster headache sufferers, of whom 21 had chronic cluster headaches. Half of those who tried LSD reported complete relief.

Researchers are trying to study a version of LSD (brominated LSD) that does not cause hallucinations. This form of LSD was reported in the journal Cephalalgia to stop cluster attacks in all five patients it was given to. It is not clear if any additional studies are underway, but one American doctor, John Halpern is trying to bring this product to the market in the US.

Trying to obtain LSD or hallucinogenic mushrooms carries legal risks, including incarceration. According to Dr. McGeeney, who is an Assistant Professor at Boston University School of Medicine, it is legal to buy, cultivate, and sell seeds of certain hallucinogenic plants, such as Rivea Corymbosa, Hawaiian baby woodrose, and certain strains of morning glory seeds. However, it is not legal to ingest them.

The bottom line is that I urge my patients not to try hallucinogens because their safety has not been established. This is especially true for illicit products, which may contain additional toxic substances.

Fortunately, we do not need to resort to these agent because we have such a variety of safer and legal products. These include preventive medications, such as verapamil in high doses, topiramate, lithium, and for chronic cluster headaches, Botox injections. None of these drugs are approved by the FDA and are not likely to be approved because this is a relatively rare condition, which makes performing large studies very difficult. The only FDA-approved drug for cluster headaches is an abortive drug, injectable sumatriptan (Imitrex).

Read More

Two new migraine drugs are about to be released on the market. They were mentioned in this blog in their earlier stages of development. Another two drugs are more interesting, but are several years away from becoming available (if at all).

Zecuity is a patch that delivers sumatriptan (active ingredient in Imitrex) through the skin. The patch contains a small battery and the electric current it generates helps the medicine penetrate through the skin. The patch is particularly useful when migraine is accompanied by nausea and vomiting. The main side effect of the patch, compared to the tablet, is that it causes irritation of the skin in one third of patients. This product was already approved by the FDA and will be soon available in pharmacies from its manufacturer, Teva Pharmaceuticals.

Levadex is a drug inhaled into the lungs using a device similar to those used for asthma drugs. It contains dihydroergotamine – a very old and very effective injectable drug. Dihydroergotamine does not work well in a nasal spray (Migranal) or when taken by mouth. Levadex causes less side effects, such as nausea, than the injection of this drug. The main target population for this drug is also migraine sufferers who experience nausea and vomiting and for whom tablets do not work. Because it works very fast it may be also very effective for those whose headache starts and escalates to a severe intensity very quickly, which includes not only migraine, but also cluster headache sufferers. Levadex is manufactured by Allergan, the company that also makes Botox. It should be available in the next few months.

Lasmitidan is a new drug being developed by CoLucid. It is in phase III trials, which is the final phase, which if successful, can lead to the FDA approval. Lasmitidan is a new type of drug – it targets a specific serotonin receptor subtype – 1F, while triptans (sumatriptan, rizatriptan, and other) target 1B and 1D serotonin receptors. It may have the advantage of not constricting arteries at all and may be allowed in patients with coronary artery disease. Triptans are contraidicated in such patients.

Merck is developing a drug, which does not have a name yet, only a number – MK-1602. It is a CGRP receptor antagonist – a blocker of a neurotransmitter in the brain that is involved in migraine origination. It is in phase II trials. MK-1602 also has the advantage of not constricting arteries. At least two other companies are developing CGRP antibodies (different from CGRP antagonists) and they were mentioned in a recent post here.

Read More

The versatility of botulinum toxin continues to amaze. The use of botulinum toxin (Botox) for the treatment of migraine headaches (pioneered at the New York Headache Center) is becoming widespread in the US. The original FDA-approved indications for botulinum toxin was a rare eye condition, blepharospasm as well as strabismus. The number of indications (not all of them yet FDA-approved) for botulinum toxin has increased very quickly – from cosmetic use for wrinkles to gastrointestinal disorders (narrowing of the esophagus, rectal fissures), excessive sweating, muscle spasticity of cerebral palsy and following a stroke, neuropathic pain (neuropathy, trigeminal neuralgia, shingles), spastic bladder (which causes frequent urination), and other.

Injecting botulinum toxin into the fat pads around the heart after coronary bypass surgery seems to reduce the incidence of atrial fibrillation, an irregular hear beat. This is the conclusion of a randomized and blinded study of 60 patients, half of whom were injected with saline water and the other half with botulinum toxin (not Botox, but one of the other 3 botulinum toxin products, Xeomin).

Patients who received injections of botulinum toxin instead of saline water had a significantly lower rate of irregular heart beats in the first 30 days (30% versus 7%), according to Evgeny Pokushalov, MD, PhD, of the State Research Institute of Circulation Pathology in Novosibirsk, Russia. Injections of botulinum toxin around the heart did not cause any complications or side effects. These irregularities of heart rhythm can be dangerous and if these findings are confirmed, botulinum toxin injections may become standard during coronary bypass surgery. If these injections are indeed effective they would also save money by reducing the duration of hospital stay and preventing the need for additional treatments of irregular heart beat.

Read More

Triptans, such as Imitrex or sumatriptan and similar drugs are “designer” drugs which were developed to specifically treat migraine headaches. They are highly effective and, after more than 20 years on the market, proven safe. Four out of the seven drugs in this category (Imitrex, Maxalt, Zomig, Amerge) are available in a generic form, which significantly lowers their cost, which was one of the obstacles for their widespread use. So, it would appear that now there is no reason for doctors not to prescribe triptans to migraine sufferers.

In 1998, emergency department doctors gave more than half of the patients suffering from migraine headaches opioids (narcotics) to relieve pain and, according to a new study, 12 years later, this hasn’t changed.

Despite the fact that triptans are widely considered to be the best drugs for acute migraine, the use of these drugs in the emergency department has remained at 10%, according to a study led by Benjamin Friedman, an emergency medicine doctor at the Montefiore Medical Center in the Bronx.

In 1998, about 51% of patients presenting with migraine at the emergency department were treated with an injection of a narcotic and in 2010, narcotics were given to 53% of the patients.

Other than narcotics (opioids) emergency department doctors often give injections of an NSAID (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug) Toradol (ketorolac) or a nausea drug, such as Reglan (metoclopramide). These two drugs are more effective (especially if given together) and have fewer potential side effects than narcotics. They also do not cause addiction and rebound (medication overuse) headaches, which narcotics do.

Dr. Friedman and his colleagues looked at the national data for 2010 and found that there were 1.2 million visits to the emergency departments for the treatment of migraine. Migraine was the 5th most common reason people come to the emergency room.

They also discovered that people who were given a triptan in the emergency department had an average length of stay in the ER of 90 minutes, while those given Dilaudid (hydromorphone) – the most popular narcotic, stayed in the ER for an average of 178 minutes.

Opioids should be used only occasionally – when triptans, ketorolac, and metoclopramide are ineffective or are contraindicated. This should be the case in maybe 5% of these patients, according to Dr. Friedman

One possible reason why ER doctors do not follow recommended treatments and use narcotics instead, is that they do not recognize a severe headache as migraine and misdiagnose it as sinus, tension-type or just as a “severe headache”. Many doctors still believe that migraine has to be a one-sided headache, or a visual aura must precede a migraine, or that the pain has to be throbbing. It is well established that none of these features are required for the diagnosis of migraine.

Another possible reason for the widespread use of opioid drugs in the ER is that doctors are very accustomed to using them, while triptans may be unfamiliar and require thinking about potential contraindications, what dose to give, what side effects to expect, etc.

In summary, if you or someone you know has to go to an ER with a severe migraine, ask for injectable sumatriptan (which you should have at home to avoid such visits to the ER) or ketorolac.

Read More

Antibodies blocking a specific neurotransmitter involved in migraines appear to relieve migraine headaches. Two studies presented at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Neurology reported on the use of antibodies to CGRP (calcitonin gene-related peptide) for the treatment of migraine headaches. These were relatively small, but highly scientific (randomized, double-blind, and placebo-controlled) studies. The studies was conducted in patients with frequent migraines.

The two studies used two different antibodies developed by different companies. The results of the trials suggest that this approach is both effective and safe in preventing migraine, at least according to these preliminary studies.

If these antibodies are proven to be indeed safe and effective, they will be the first specific migraine therapy since the introduction of triptans over 20 years ago. Triptans (sumatriptan and other) are abortive drugs, meaning that abort a migraine attack, while CGRP antibodies are used for the preventive (prophylactic) treatment. While Botox was approved three years ago for the preventive treatment of chronic migraines it was not specifically developed for the treatment of migraines. Instead, Botox was found to have this effect accidentally.

One phase II proof-of-concept trial enrolled 218 people with 4 to 14 migraine headache days per month and randomly assigned them to get the antibody or a placebo. The study medication was given every 2 weeks by subcutaneous injection. Active treatment resulted in reduction of an average of 4.2 migraine days per month in the third month for those on the active drug and a drop of 3.0 days for those on placebo.

The side effects were similar between the groups and most were mild and resolved on their own.

In the other study the antibody was given intravenously at the start of the trial, with an hour-long infusion, but was not repeated. This study enrolled 163 patients, with 82 assigned to the drug and 81 to placebo. The average change from baseline in migraine days per month was a decline of 5.6 for the active treatment compared with a drop of 4.6 for placebo patients. Side effects in this study were also mild and occurred with the same frequency in the active and placebo groups.

While the difference between the active treatment and placebo does not seem to be significant, it was statistically significant and it is possible that some patients will respond very well while others not at all.

The next step is much larger phase III studies, which typically involve over 1,000 patients for each compound. If phase III studies also show safety and efficacy of these antibodies, then the FDA might approve them. This means that the earliest one or both of these drugs will become available is about 3 years.

The companies that sponsored these studies were Arteaus and Alder Biopharmaceuticals.

Read More

Epidural steroid injections are popular for persistent neck and back pains. Patients with migraine and other headaches often have neck pain as well and if they happen to visit an anesthesiologist/pain specialist instead of a neurologist, there is a good chance they will be offered a cervical epidural steroid injection. If you or someone you know are offered such injections, just say no.

Despite the widespread use of this procedure, there is no good scientific evidence that these injections help. Not only they probably do not help, they can cause serious side effects. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is warning that injection of corticosteroids into the epidural space of the spine may result in rare but serious adverse events, including loss of vision, stroke, paralysis, and death.

The FDA is requiring the addition of a warning to the drug labels of injectable corticosteroids to describe these risks.

The FDA said that “Injectable corticosteroids are commonly used to reduce swelling or inflammation. Injecting corticosteroids into the epidural space of the spine has been a widespread practice for many decades; however, the effectiveness and safety of the drugs for this use have not been established, and the FDA has not approved corticosteroids for such use.”

The FDA reviewed cases of serious neurological adverse events associated with epidural corticosteroid injections. Serious adverse events included death, spinal cord infarction, paraplegia, quadriplegia, cortical blindness, stroke, seizures, nerve injury, and brain edema.

Some doctors perform these injections under X-ray guidance, but even then serious neurological complications can occur. X-ray guidance also exposes patients to harmful radiation and increases the cost of the procedure, which is significant even without the X-ray.

This FDA warning is unrelated to a recent disastrous contamination of corticosteroids used for epidural injections. This contamination occurred at a compounding pharmacy in Massachusetts and resulted in 749 patients contracting fungal meningitis with 61 patients dying from it. This is another reason to avoid epidurals.

Read More

An oral tablet is the most convenient way to take medicine. However, many migraine sufferers wake up with a headache that is in full bloom and severe nausea or vomiting makes it difficult to take oral medications. Others find that tablets are ineffective or take too long to work.

Sumatriptan (Imitrex), the miracle migraine drug which has changed lives of millions of migraine and cluster headache sufferers, was first released in an injection. The injection is still available and is the most effective way to stop a migraine. The injection comes in a variety of pre-filled syringes and cartridges, which are very easy to self-inject. The problem with injections is that some people don’t like the idea of injecting themselves, which is surprising, considering how much pain and suffering they endure from migraine. Another problem is the cost – even in a generic form a shot costs $35 (see GoodRx.com for cheapest prices). The biggest reason why injections are underutilized is that doctors fail to offer this option to patients, many of whom would be happy to use it.

Nasal sprays offer a middle ground option – not as fast or effective as an injection, but faster and sometimes more effective than a tablet. There are several medications available in a nasal spray. The same triptan medication, sumatriptan comes in a nasal spray. However, another triptan, zolmitriptan (Zomig NS) in my experience is more effective. The disadvantage of Zomig is that it is very expensive if not covered by insurance (over $200 a spray) because it is not available in a generic form.

Another nasal spray approved for migraine headaches is Migranal. It contains dihydroergotamine, which is one of the strongest injectable migraine drugs. However, it is much less effective in a nasal spray form. It is also very expensive – $200 a dose. Dihydroergotamine is about to be released in an inhaler. It will be called Levadex and will deliver the medicine into the lungs. Its efficacy should be as good as that of an injection, but with fewer side effects. Hopefully, it will not be more expensive than the generic sumatriptan injection. Otherwise, just like with Migranal, insurance companies will not cover it.

Sprix is a nasal spray containing ketorolac. In a tablet form (Toradol) ketorolac is no more effective than aspirin and is more irritating to the stomach. But it is a very effective drug for migraines when it is injected and to a lesser extent, when sprayed into the nose. It is very popular as an injection in the ERs and at our New York Headache Center. Sprix can sometimes irritate the nasal passages. It costs about $35 a dose.

Stadol (butorphanol) is a narcotic (opioid) pain killer, which costs about $30 a dose in a generic form. It does relieve pain well and is approved for migraine headaches. However, just like other narcotics, it is potentially addictive. Also, many migraine sufferers find that narcotics do not help their migraine and often makes them feel sicker. It also costs over $30 a dose.

There are several over-the-counter nasal sprays containing hot pepper extract, capsaicin. There is no good scientific evidence that these capsaicin products sprayed into the nose relieve migraines or cluster headaches. On the other hand, besides burning and irritation of the nasal passages, they have few side effects and are inexpensive.

Read More

A good predictor of response to Botox injections in chronic migraine patients has been found by Spanish researchers.

While Botox is a very effective treatment for chronic migraines and possibly other types of headaches and pain, it does not help everyone. Approximately 30% of patients with chronic migraine headaches do not respond to Botox. We usually try at least two sets of injections three months apart before considering the patient to be a non-responder. Considering that Botox is an expensive treatment, it would be very useful to know beforehand which patients will respond and which will not. Besides the cost, it would also save patients time, during which they could be trying other treatments.

Some studies show that having a constricting headache or pain in the eye is usually a positive predictor of response to Botox. On the other hand, exploding headache (that is when the pain is felt pushing from the inside out), is less likely to respond to Botox injections. However, these are very subjective descriptions and predictions based on them are not that reliable.

A new study by Spanish researchers just published in the journal Headache reported that the levels of CGRP (calcitonin gene-related peptide) and VIP (vasoactive intestinal peptide) in patients’ blood are good predictors of response to Botox in chronic migraine sufferers. These two chemicals, which circulate in the blood and perform various important functions in the brain have long been the subject of scientific research. Actually, we think that Botox works by blocking the release of CGRP from the peripheral nerve endings. Dr. Julio Pascual and his colleagues measured the levels of these two chemicals in chronic migraine patients before they were treated with Botox. Botox was administered according to the standard protocol every 12 weeks for at least two treatment cycles. A patient was considered a moderate responder when both: 1) moderate-severe headache episodes were reduced by between 33 and 66%; and 2) subjective benefit on a visual scale from 0 to 100 was recorded by the patient of between 33-66%. Patients were considered to be excellent responders when both items improved by more than 66%. Those without improvement of at least one-third in the two items were considered as nonresponders.

The study involved 81 patients with chronic migraine and 33 healthy controls. CGRP and VIP levels were significantly increased in the chronic migraine population vs controls. CGRP and, to a lesser degree, VIP levels were significantly increased in responders vs nonresponders. The probability of being a responder to Botox was 28 times higher in patients with a CGRP level above the threshold.

The measurement of CGRP and VIP is done only by research institutions and is not yet offered by commercial laboratories. However, considering how much money can be saved by not giving Botox to those who are unlikely to respond, these tests should become widely available once these findings are confirmed by other researchers.

Read More

Yesterday, the FDA approved the first preventive (prophylactic) treatment for migraines in adolescents – kids between the ages of 12 and 17. Topamax (topiramate) was first approved by the FDA in 1996 to prevent seizures. It was approved for migraine prevention in adults in 2004.
As the FDA stated in its announcement, “Migraine headaches can impact school performance, social interactions, and family life. Adding dosing and safety information for the adolescent age group to the drug’s prescribing information will help to inform health care professionals and patients in making treatment choices.”
The announcement also stated that “About 12 percent of the U.S. population experiences migraine headaches. Migraine headaches are characterized by episodes of throbbing and pulsating pain in the head, and may occur several times per month. Other common symptoms include increased sensitivity to light, noise, and odors, as well as nausea and vomiting. Many patients experience their first migraine attack before reaching adulthood, and migraine can be just as disabling in teens as it is in adults.

The safety and effectiveness of Topamax in preventing migraine headaches in adolescents ages 12 to 17 was established in a clinical trial that enrolled 103 participants. Those treated with Topamax experienced a decrease in the frequency of migraine of approximately 72 percent compared to 44 percent in participants that took an inactive drug (placebo).

The most common adverse reactions with the approved dose of Topamax (100 milligrams) were paresthesia (a burning or prickling sensation felt in the hands, arms, legs, or feet), upper respiratory infection, anorexia (loss of appetite), and abdominal pain.

Topamax increases the risk of the development of cleft lip and/or cleft palate (oral clefts) in infants born to women who take the drug during pregnancy. The benefits and risks of Topamax should be carefully weighed before using it in women of childbearing age. If the decision is made to use the medication by a woman of childbearing age, effective birth control should be used.”

It is a little surprising that the FDA based its approval on such as small study – 103 patients. I should add that topiramate can also cause cognitive side effects, such as memory and word retrieval problems in a significant percentage of children and adults. Approximately 20% of adults taking topiramate for more than a year or two develop kidney stones. This most likely can also happen in children. As you can tell from this and my previous posts, I am not a big fan of Topamax. In kids particularly we begin with life style and dietary changes, biofeedback, magnesium, CoQ10 and other supplements and even Botox injections, which are very safe, before resorting to prophylactic drugs such as topiramate.
Julie Mauskop
Art credit: JulieMauskop.com

Read More

The beneficial effect of Botox on mood has been reported for years. I mentioned this in one of my blog posts in 2011. Now, a new and highly scientific study (double-blind, placebo-controlled) which is about to be published in the Journal of Psychiatric Research confirms that Botox relieves depression. The study is described in today’s New York Times.

I have also heard from many of my own patients who receive Botox for chronic migraines that their mood improves, although in their case it could be to a great extent because their headaches improve.

Read More

A severe migraine attack can sometimes land you in an emergency room. With its bright lights, noise, and long waits, it is the last place you want to be in. To add insult to the injury, some doctors will think that you are looking for narcotic drugs and treat you with suspicion, while others will offer ibuprofen tablets. It is hard to think clearly when you are in the throes of a migraine, so you need to be prepared and have a list of treatments you may want to ask for, just in case the ER doctor is not good at treating migraines.

If you are vomiting, first ask for intravenous hydration and insist on having at least 1 gram of magnesium added to the intravenous fluids. Everyone with severe migraines should have sumatriptan (Imitrex) injection at home since it often eliminates the need to go to an ER in the first place. If you haven’t taken a shot at home, ask for one in the ER. The next best drug is a non-narcotic pain medicine, ketorolac (Toradol) and if you are nauseous, metoclopramide (Reglan). Do not let the doctor start your treatment with divalproex sodium (Depakene, drug similar to an oral drug for migraine prophylaxis, Depakote) or opioid (narcotic drugs) such as demerol, morphine, hydromorphone and other.

This post was prompted by an article just published in the journal Neurology by emergency room doctors at the Montefiore Hospital in the Bronx. It was a double-blind trial which compared intravenous infusion of 1,000 mg of sodium valproate with 10 mg metoclopramide, and with 30 mg ketorolac. They looked at relief of headache by 1 hour, measured on a verbal 0 to 10 scale. They also recorded how many patients needed another rescue medication and how many had sustained headache freedom.

Three hundred thirty patients were enrolled in the study. Those on divalproex improved by a mean of 2.8 points, those receiving IV metoclopramide improved by 4.7 points, and those receiving IV ketorolac improved by 3.9 points. 69% of those given valproate required rescue medication, compared with 33% of metoclopramide patients and 52% of those assigned to ketorolac. Sustained headache freedom was achieved in 4% of those randomized to valproate, 11% of metoclopramide patients, and 16% receiving ketorolac. In the metoclopramide arm, 6% of patients reported feeling “very restless”, which can be a very unpleasant side effect of this drug.

The authors concluded that the valproate was less efficacious than either metoclopramide or ketorolac. Metoclopramide was somewhat better than ketorolac but it also had more side effects.

To summarize, ask the doctor to start with hydration and magnesium, then sumatriptan injection, followed by metoclopramide and ketorolac, if needed. If the above treatments do not help, we also give dexamethasone (Decadron, a steroid medication) and DHE-45 (dihydroergotamine). All these medications can be administered in the office and we always tell our patients not to go to an ER and to come into the office if the attack occurs during our office hours.

Read More

Trigeminal neuralgia (TN) is an excruciatingly painful disorder which affects about one in a thousand people. Patients describe the pain of TN as an electric shock going through the face. Eating and talking often triggers the pain, so some patients become malnourished and depressed. The pain is brief, but can be so frequent and severe that it causes severe disability, weight loss, severe anxiety, and depression. The good news is that most people can obtain relief by taking drugs, such as Tegretol (carbamazepine), Trileptal (oxcarbazepine), Dilantin (phenytoin), or Lioresal (baclofen). I have successfully treated several patients who did not respond to these medications with Botox injections.

Patients who do not respond to medications or Botox injections have several surgical options available. According to a new Dutch “Nationwide study of three invasive treatments for trigeminal neuralgia” published in journal Pain shows that every year about 1% of those suffering from TN undergo surgery. Of the three most common types of surgery, percutaneous radiofrequency thermocoagulation (PRT) is by far most popular – in a three year period in Holland, 672 patients underwent PRT, 87 underwent microvascular decompression (MVD), and 39 underwent partial sensory rhizotomy (PSR). The latter two procedures a performed by neurosurgeons (MVD requires opening of the skull), while PRT is usually done by anesthesiologists (a probe is inserted through the cheek to the nerve ganglion under X-ray guidance). MVD was most effective, but caused more complications than PRT, although fewer than with PSR. More patients having PRT had to have a repeat procedure, but it was still safer than the other two. Very often the physician under-treats during the first treatment of PRT in order to avoid complications. Overall, the best initial procedure for those suffering with TN is PRT and if repeated PRTs fail, MVD can often cure this condition.

Read More